Best Pizza

A & A Pagliai's Pizza

302 E. Bloomington St., Iowa City

Since 1962, Pagliai's pizza has stuck by a simple rule: Do one thing and do it right. The venerable Iowa City landmark has been using the same pizza recipe since opening almost 50 years ago, and serves nothing but pizza, pop and beer. It's been voted Iowa City's favorite pizza joint for every year of our competition.

Mug shot of winner

 

Runners-up: Wig & Pen, The Wedge

Last year’s winner: Pagliai's Pizza

« Previous | Next »